England's captaincy options: Who could do the job after Joe Root?

The cupboard of replacements is hardly full. The Cricketer takes a look at the possible successors to Root as England Test skipper...

captains28032209

Take out a digital subscription with The Cricketer for just £1 for the first month

On Friday, April 15, Joe Root confirmed his resignation as England captain. The Cricketer takes a look at the possible successors...

Ben Stokes 

Allrounder, current Test vice-captain and general workhouse.

Pros: Stokes has already done the job (in Root's absence for paternity reasons in 2020, and in last year's ODIs against Pakistan), he is an established figure in the dressing room and perhaps the only other member of the team who is 100 per cent undroppable. He has the respect of the dressing room, vast knowledge about the international game, and a serious competitive streak.

Cons: He has really only just come back from a prolonged break from the game for mental health reasons, and the additional strain of the captaincy does not necessarily feel a sensible next step. Given his huge workload with bat and ball, and in the field - where he is one of the team's main assets - captaincy could prove overbearing. There is an added complexity to how the transition between Root and Stokes would work, with Stokes unlikely to look favourably on any sacking of his friend. 

Captaincy potential: 4/5

stokes25032201

Ben Stokes is the natural successor to Joe Root

Stuart Broad

England's second most decorated fast bowler

Pros: Broad has experience of the England captaincy, albeit in T20 cricket. He knows the landscape, speaks particularly well in public and has the sympathy of the media. 

Cons: This would be a short-term appointment - Broad is 35 and England have already suggested he is disposable by leaving him out of the Caribbean tour. England would have to happily put their tail between their legs, having dropped him the very series before making him captain.

Captaincy potential: 3/5

captains28032201

Stuart Broad was left out of the Caribbean tour

Sam Billings

Kent wicketkeeper-bat, white-ball gun

Pros: Billings is not a stranger to the captain's role - he has been club captain at Kent for some time and led Oval Invincibles in last year's Hundred. He's also been skipper of England Lions. Billings would be an external appointment - he's only played one Test - and would bring with him an element of a fresh start. A good communicator.

Cons: Billings' first-class record, while good, is not necessarily strong enough to encourage selection on its own, and his captaincy, while good, is not exceptional enough to demand inclusion on a sort of Mike Brearley basis. Would his presence confuse the wicketkeeper question, too?

Captaincy potential: 2/5

captains28032203

Sam Billings has only played one Test

Rory Burns

Currently opener-non-grata. Championship run machine

Pros: Burns is an established and decorated captain, having led Surrey to the County Championship. He knows the Test arena, having been in and out of the national side since the backend of 2018. He is probably England's best option at the top of the order of all those tried since the retirement of Alastair Cook. 

Cons: Opening the batting is a tough art in the current climate. Opening in England is even tougher. Opening in England while dealing with the captaincy could be overkill. Burns' technique - already very unusual - looked all over the place in Australia and he may need time to rediscover his best rhythm before being considered for a return, let alone as captain. 

Captaincy potential rating: 1/5

captains28032205

Rory Burns was dropped after a poor Ashes series

Tom Abell

Somerset skipper, left-field option

Pros: Abell would represent a completely fresh start for English Test cricket, cutting all ties with any existing 'boys' club'. He has known captaincy for most of his career, having become Somerset skipper at 23 years old. 

Cons: Abell averages 32 with the bat and 29 with the ball in first-class cricket, and as such is a batting allrounder at a time when England have better batting allrounder options, especially at home. A command of respect across the board is always going to be hard to come by when you are parachuted into a team as captain.

Captaincy potential rating: 0.5/5

captains28032204

Tom Abell has captained Somerset for five years

James Vince

Batting enigma

Pros: Has existing leadership experience, as captain of Hampshire. Has Test experience (13 caps). Could allow Joe Root to drop back down to No.4 and focus on his batting.

Cons: Has consistently failed to take his chance as a batsman in Test cricket. May not be the charismatic leader the ECB could do with from a PR and communications perspective. 

Captaincy potential rating: 0.5/5

captains28032202

James Vince is Hampshire skipper

Eoin Morgan

White-ball kingpin

Pros: The school of thought is that Morgan knows how to lead a country to success, and could therefore translate that white-ball work into the Test arena.

Cons: The quite obvious flaw is that Morgan has not really given red-ball cricket serious consideration since before the Brexit vote. 

Captaincy potential rating: 0.01/5

 


Related Topics

Comments

Posted by Richard Vaughton on 19/04/2022 at 15:18

That looks like a typical pundits' list. Some have to be stuff of dreams. Who was JR's previous V/c .... one J BUTTLER, perhaps without the gloves...... has had impacts at test level. So why not, compared to the others?? Perhaps a well respected county captain getting a lot out of limited resources is one MOEEN ALI.... one remembers that he too has made impacts at test level..... shades of the appt of one Ray Illingworth.

Posted by Steve Thornton on 15/04/2022 at 22:40

My comment on treading that list is that we are in the deep stuff. Only the first two on the list can be seriously entertained for a place in an England test side. Broad for me for this summer in English conditions but this may need to change next winter. Underlines again the stupidity of leaving Broad at home last winter.

Posted by Marc Evans on 15/04/2022 at 22:13

For me Burns is first choice as he's our best opening option at the moment, so should be given a run in the side. Broad in the short term is an option, but he may have bùrned his bridges with the ECB following his comments about the Windies tour selection. Stokes has the attributes but his recent physical and mental issues cast doubt on his suitability. Billings would likely signal the end of Foukes as keeper, but he didn't excel on the Windies tour when he had his opportunity to stake a claim. However the problem is far deeper than anew captain can correct. We need a better white/red balance.

Posted by chris coke on 15/04/2022 at 19:58

Root's departure was inevitable ! Given the history of Test all-rounders such as Botham and Flintoff as captains I do not think it is advisable to go for Stokes. The captain needs to have tactical ability( which I am unsure that Root possessed ) and above all the respect of the players. The advantage of going with either Broad or Billings is that they are not in the current Test squad clique.

Posted by R Vaughton on 30/03/2022 at 10:49

"Joe Root's position as England Test captain is bordering on untenable" So easy / glib to write / say. So don't bother when all you can offer is the above. Why not give Mike Brearley a ring. The quality of player is not available at the moment. Look at the development of Labuschagne.... now ask why not in England

Posted by Tony Blackshaw on 29/03/2022 at 14:15

Leave our Tom Abell out of your reckoning! We need him here in Somerset.

Posted by Allan Young on 29/03/2022 at 07:01

I wonder what score and comments Mike Brearley would have been given?

LATEST NEWS

STAY UP TO DATE Sign up to our newsletter...
SIGN UP

Thank You! Thank you for subscribing!

Units 7-8, 35-37 High St, Barrow upon Soar, Loughborough, LE128PY

website@thecricketer.com

Welcome to www.thecricketer.com - the online home of the world’s oldest cricket magazine. Breaking news, interviews, opinion and cricket goodness from every corner of our beautiful sport, from village green to national arena.