Alex Hales might be devastated but this was the right reaction from the ECB... England must be on message

SIMON HUGHES: Hales’ dreams of World Cup heroics have been dashed. Of course that is devastating. But in spite of the promises made to him by officials that have turned out to be false, he has only himself to blame

haless300401-min

Take out a digital subscription with The Cricketer for just £1 for the first month

Despite another communication vacuum at the ECB, Alex Hales doesn’t have a leg to stand on regarding his omission from the preliminary England World Cup squad.

He has been found guilty of a second recreational drugs transgression and he was already on official behaviour-watch after his involvement in the fracas outside the Bristol nightclub in September 2017.

His punishment then was a £17,500 fine and a six-match ban, part of which was suspended pending good behaviour. He hasn’t kept his side of the bargain. He recently admitted being guilty of some ‘poor decision making’.

It is a bit late confessing that now. He is 30 years old not 18. 

haless300402-min

Alex Hales has lost his place in England's World Cup squad

The situation, discussed on this week's The Analyst podcast, has not been helped by the ECB communications department being in flux.

The director Chris Haynes in the process of handing over to a successor (Kate Miller, who doesn’t officially start until July). The rumour mill was always going to work overtime once Hales missed the beginning of the season for Notts for ‘personals reasons.’

It was short-sighted of officials to imagine they could slide Hales back into the World Cup squad without the truth ultimately emerging. It shows little comprehension of an admittedly voracious media.

But it is better that it comes out now than halfway through the tournament. 

Hales’ dreams of World Cup heroics have been dashed. Of course that is devastating. But in spite of the promises made to him by officials that have turned out to be false, he has only himself to blame.

"We all make mistakes. Everyone deserves a second chance. But Hales has had that, twice, and squandered it. He can’t be trusted"

With his track record - and the general reappraisal of team culture after Bristol - he had to be whiter than white. Ben Stokes totally understands that.

He has said publicly that Bristol was a sort of watershed moment, and admitted privately that the after-match culture of the England one-day side had become a bit excessive.

He rarely goes out now (spending much of his leisure time at the IPL with his father and brother) and donated a six-figure sum to a Rajasthan rehabilitation centre for victims of child slavery which he also visited. He exudes dedication to his team and the game. 

We all make mistakes. Everyone deserves a second chance. But Hales has had that, twice, and squandered it. He can’t be trusted.

A month away from a challenge that has been four years in the planning, and 44 years in waiting (since the first men's World Cup) England cannot afford anyone not 100 per cent on message.

Comments

Posted by ian Allan on 13/05/2019 at 19:34

It up to the England selectors and management to decide if they pick Alex Hales again not correspondent.

Posted by Richard Vaughton on 02/05/2019 at 18:12

I have just read Giles' explanation as to why Hales was dropped. What a wishy-washy start to the career of cricket's "El Supremo". Absolute cop-out and spineless. Not looking good for a (Giles) cricket future.

Posted by Lloyd Birch on 01/05/2019 at 12:41

Hales only has himself to blame. How many chances does he need? When will the penny drop?

Posted by Geoffrey Reilley on 01/05/2019 at 00:12

A very severe but justified decision by the powers that be. Well summarised by Simon Hughes (as usual) and hopefully a stern message for any younger person wanting to reach the top of their chosen sport. The game is too important to allow those who would bring cricket into disrepute by foolish and selfish actions.

Posted by Steve Kirk on 30/04/2019 at 17:54

Another triumph for the ECB ? The Cricketer is a publication of some influence perhaps they could ask Harrison , Graves and Co for their (seemingly ) less than straightforward part in this debacle .

Posted by Jon Harrap on 30/04/2019 at 15:39

That’s all very well with what’s happening to Alex Hales but who’s going to hold the ECB to account over the lies they told

Posted by Kate Higgs on 30/04/2019 at 15:29

I can't agree more. Hales is a gifted cricketer in a privileged position but has squandered his chances,letting down himself and team mates. At 30yrs old he should know better

Posted by John Nicholson on 30/04/2019 at 15:25

If the ECB ever though they could get away with giving Hales yet another slap on the wrist, then they are as dumb as Hales himself. The law abiding public are not stupid.

Posted by Neil Smith on 30/04/2019 at 14:00

Simon, thanks for the piece. I agree that England has now made a sensible decision. However I'm not sure comments such as "only himself to blame" and "he can't be trusted" are helpful. These are quite personal criticisms in a situation where many of us don't know either Hales' mental state or the full facts (though I accept you might know more). And many people make bad decisions beyond the age of 30 !

LATEST NEWS

STAY UP TO DATE Sign up to our newsletter...
SIGN UP

Thank You! Thank you for subscribing!

Units 7-8, 35-37 High St, Barrow upon Soar, Loughborough, LE128PY

website@thecricketer.com

Welcome to www.thecricketer.com - the online home of the world’s oldest cricket magazine. Breaking news, interviews, opinion and cricket goodness from every corner of our beautiful sport, from village green to national arena.